The Practical Nomad blog: Passenger Name Records (PNR) in practice: a case study

Tuesday, 13 April 2010

Passenger Name Records (PNR) in practice: a case study

I spoke about Passenger Name Record (PNR) data as a case study in the relationship of EU policies to the realities of industry and US government practice at the European Privacy OS conference today in Oxford (UK). Some links for more information:

Slides with annotation
How to request your own travel records
US and EU use of ICAO for policy laundering on PNR data, passports, other travel documents, and related databases and processes
2010 Identity Project update on DHS non-compliance with the PNR agreement
2008 Identity Project analysis of DHS non-compliance with the PNR agreement
2007 Identity Project report on the first DHS responses to requests for PNR data
Background: What's in a PNR?
Insecure Web portals for PNR retrieval
Related events

Link | Posted by Edward on Tuesday, 13 April 2010, 22:44 (10:44 PM)

caricature of Edward Hasbrouck by Rhoda Grossman, www.digitalpainting.com

Subscribe to my free travel newsletter! Send me an e-mail message at

and I will add you to my mailing list.

(More info)

Around-The-World Airline Tickets

Around-the-world tickets from Airtreks.com

Around-The-World and Multi-Stop International Airline Tickets

Airtreks.com (USA and worldwide)
Long Haul Travel (Canada)

Hostelling International

Hostelling International

Archives by Topic

Archives by Date

(since October 2003)

Archived Entries (complete list for all dates)

Search

Recent Entries

An "Airline Passengers' Bill Of Rights"?
European Commission doesn't want to enforce its CRS rules
Former Director of Selective Service says it's time to end draft registration
My testimony to the National Commission on Military Service
The Amazing Race 31, Episode 1
WOW Air is bankrupt
How writers monetize words: The marketplaces for writing in digital formats
BBC "Race Across the World"
What's wrong with automated facial recognition in airports?
Federal court declares current military draft registration requirement unconstitutional

FAQs and How-tos:

I use AOL, and I didn't get your newsletter, or didn't get an answer to my e-mail message. What's wrong?
I use Yahoo, and I didn't get your newsletter, or didn't get an answer to my e-mail message. What's wrong?

What's in a Passenger Name Record (PNR)?
What records does the government keep about my travels?
How to request your travel records (with sample forms)
How safe is airline passenger data? Not secure at all.
Public demonstration of airline reservation hacking
What can I do to protect my PNR data?
Does the REAL-ID Act mean I have to show ID to fly? (No.)

FAQ About Airline Bankruptcies
FAQ About Changes to Flights and Tickets
FAQ About Travel Insurance
Do governments subsidize airlines? (Yes!)
Airlines lie about codesharing
More about airline alliances and code-sharing
How to pursue a complaint against an airline (Ben Edelman)

Do I need to be young, strong, and fit to travel? (No.)
Most useful languages for world travel?
Smartphones and digital maps for world travel:
Part 1, Part 2, Part 3

How does hotel discounting work? (part 1)
Online hotel discount directory (part 2)
"Shills" and fake reviews on travel Web sites
What happens when a hotel price is a "mistake"?

What's the real story about the REAL-ID Act and air travel?
How can I get a new a new passport in a hurry?
FAQ About Secure Flight

The Identity Project

PapersPlease.org

News from The Identity Project
Identity Project policy analysis and research
First Amendment Project

Freedom To Travel As A Human Right

"Congress shall make no law ... abridging ... the right of the people peaceably to assemble." (U.S. Constitution)

"Everyone has the right to freedom of movement and residence within the borders of each state. Everyone has the right to leave any country, including his own, and to return to his country." (Universal Declaration of Human Rights)

"Liberty of movement is an indispensable condition for the free development of a person." (United Nations Human Rights Committee)

Briefings on travel and civil liberties

Video: Surveillance and control of travellers (30 min.)
Video: The REAL-ID Act and ID to fly (15 min.) (More)
Audio: The REAL-ID Act and the right to travel (15 min.) (More)
Audio: DHS plans to gather social media information (7 min.)
FAQ: U.S. government monitoring of social media
Video: Is Silicon Valley building the infrastructure for a police state? (10 min.)

Edward Hasbrouck v. U.S. Customs and Border Protection

Why I sued the Department of Homeland Security
FAQ: Hasbrouck v. CBP
After more than a year, my first day in court
First rulings in our lawsuit over DHS travel records
Hasbrouck v. CBP dismissed. What have we learned?
What records does the government keep about your travel?
(with examples of records obtained obtained through my lawsuit)
Why the Judicial Redress Act is worthless

The Amazing Race

Most recent season: "The Amazing Race 31"
Previous seasons of "The Amazing Race"
How to apply for "The Amazing Race"
Articles about "The Amazing Race" in my blog

Selected Places and Regions

Trains in Russia, India, and China
Flights in Brazil, Russia, India, and China (BRIC)
China travel bargains, tips, and links

Travel in Yemen
USA ends Syria travel "warning" but keeps financial sanctions
OFAC, banks, and Syria travel sanctions

Kashmir, self-determination, and human rights

Sites of memory of state terrorism in Argentina
Bicycle Touring in Argentina

Business and pleasure in Cancún

Trains in Europe
Flights Within Europe
A visit to Hazebrouck (Flanders)
European bicycle touring resources
Bicycling the Danube: Part 1, Part 2, Part 3

Edward Hasbrouck

photo of Edward Hasbrouck

Home
About
Appearances and events
Articles
Author photos and book cover images

Follow me on Twitter

Why I'm not on Facebook (PDF)
Disclosures & Disclaimers
Contact
GnuPG/PGP public key
How to pitch me

Hasbrouck Family Association
A visit to Hazebrouck

Current Events and Concerns

Airport police attack passenge: Why did it happen? Who's to blame?
Public demonstration of CRS/GDS and PNR hacking
What's the real story about the REAL-ID Act and air travel?
Ibrahim v. DHS "No-Fly" trial
What's wrong with "personalized" airline ticket prices?
Airlines claim they are already allowed to "personalize" prices
Airline consumer protection agenda
"Shills" and fake reviews on travel Web sites
Airline ticket price transparency (Not.)
Air travel and "class war"

Google is now hosting airline reservations (PNRs)
Google acquires ITA Software: What's that mean for travellers?
Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4

Peak Travel: Envisioning a post-air-travel age
Air travel and global warming
Ecotourism and Independent Travel
Sites of memory of state terrorism in Argentina

Government surveillance and control of travel (overview)
Airlines and the human rights of migrants in transit
Travel controls and the rights of refugees and asylum seekers
Consumer Privacy and Air Travel: Recommendations to the U.S. Dept. of Transportation
Consumer groups call for action on travel privacy
"What happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas."
A new, virtual Berlin Wall? A new "Silicon Curtain"?
Testimony to the European Parliament on PNR data (2010)
Testimony to the European Parliament on PNR data (2011)
Testimony to the Canadian Parliament on PNR data
The Obama Administration and the Right to Travel
"Secure Flight"
"Advance Passenger Information System" (APIS):
Permission to travel ("Mother, may I?")
Electronic System for Travel Authorization (ESTA)
Air Canada lies about government access to reservations
KLM claims it doesn't know what happens with passengers' data
What does Air France do with reservation data?
Lufthansa says they aren't responsible for their agents and contractors
ICAO and logs of travellers' movements on RFID passports
Unanswered questions at Dulles Airport
ICANN and ".travel"
MedicalDraft.info
Resisters.info

The Practical Nomad books

book cover

book cover

The Practical Nomad: How to Travel Around the World (5th edition, 2011)
The Practical Nomad Guide to the Online Travel Marketplace
Excerpts
Reviews
Reader comments
Post your own review at Amazon.com
Ordering info

Support Independent Bookstores!

IndieBound independent bookstores

Modern Times Bookstore
Book Passage

Avalon Travel Books and Author Blogs

Travel Writing Resources

Travel writing resources
Thoughts on travel writing
Travel writing etiquette, ethics, and law
The business and pleasure of travel blogging:
Notes from the TBEX travel bloggers conference
Bay Area Travel Writers
National Writers Union (UAW Local 1981, AFL-CIO)
NWU Book Division
International Federation of Journalists (IFJ)
International Federation of Reproduction Rights Organisations (IFRRO)
Thoughts on copyright minimalism and
my election to the IFRRO Board of Directors
What do authors fear from "Orphan Works" proposals?
What's wrong with the "International Standard Name Identifier" (ISNI)?
Action on Authors' Rights (UK)
About Travel Guidebook Writing (Tom Brosnahan)
Book Passage Travel Writers Conference
Chicago Manual of Style Q & A
The Subversive Copy Editor

National Writers Union (UAW Local 1981, AFL-CIO)

NWU Priorities for Copyright Reform

I Support Bloggers' Rights.

Online Media Legal Network

Consumer Advocacy

Travelers United
Consumer Federation of America

Bicycle Travel

My articles about bicycle travel
Bicycle Travel FAQs:
Do I need to be young, strong, and fit to travel by bike? (No.)
Is it easier to travel by bicycle on your own or in a "supported" group?
FAQ and buying guide: How to buy a touring bicycle
FAQ: International bicycle travel
FAQ: Riding skills for bicycle travel
Bicycle route-finding and navigation
Bicycle touring in Argentina
Bicycle components for touring in Argentina
European bicycle touring resources
A visit to Hazebrouck (bicycling in Flanders)
Bicycle touring in England and Scotland
Bicycling the Danube: Part 1, Part 2, Part 3

Dervla Murphy
Willie Weir
Crazy Guy On A Bike (bike travel blogs)
Warm Showers (hospitality exchange)
Bicycling Street Smarts (John S. Allen), US version
Bicycling Street Smarts (John S. Allen), left-hand drive version)
Cyclecraft (John Franklin), UK edition
Cyclecraft (John Franklin), USA/Canada edition
Effective Cycling (John Forester)

Sheldon Brown, bicycle mechanic and educator
John Forester, Bicycle Transportation Engineer
John S. Allen's Bicycle Blog
John Schubert, Bicycling and Safety Consultant
Fred Oswald: Cycle Safety
Bicycle Traveler magazine
I am traffic
Cycling Savvy
Taking the Lane (Elly Blue)
Urban Adonia (Adonia Lugo)
Invisible Cyclist
The Retrogrouch
Witch on a Bicycle
Reform the League of American Bicyclists
Adventure Cycling Association ("Bikecentennial")
Roads Were Not Built For Cars
San Francisco Critical Mass
California Association of Bicycling Organizations (CABO)
"CABO forum" discussion list
Bay Citizen Bike Accident Tracker
S.F. Streetsblog
The Bike Kitchen (San Francisco)
Pedal Revolution
Warm Planet Bikes
Box Dog Bikes
R+E Cycles (Rodriguez travel bikes)
Birdy bicycles

SaveSFbike.org

Save SF Bike!
My views on the SF Bicycle Coalition "sfbike" discussion list

Links

Articles by Edward Hasbrouck at ConsumerTraveler.com

Hostelling International
OmniMap
MapLink
World Weather Guide (via BBC)
National Lawyers Guild
anonlg: Anonymous Legal Help from the NLG
#FreeAnons: Anonymous Solidarity Network
Computers, Freedom & Privacy
War Resisters League
National War Tax Resistance Coordinating Committee
WRL blog
WIN magazine (WRL)
Peacework magazine (AFSC)
ICANN Watch
Online Policy Group
TSA News Blog
Tourism Concern
Ethical Traveler
Aviation Environment Federation (UK)
International Coalition for Sustainable Aviation
Work to Live
Take Back Your Time
Learning Service: Rethinking Volunteer Travel
World Hum
San Francisco Travel Book Club and Lectures Series
Meet, Plan, Go!
Perceptive Travel
The Transnational
The Beat (business travel)
Tnooz ("talking travel tech")
Associated Press travel news
Flyertalk travel security forum
Pecha Kucha - San Francisco
Pecha Kucha - global
FOIA Letter Generator (RCFP)
Committee to Protect Journalists
Freedom of the Press Foundation
International Coalition for Sustainable Aviation
CRÉLOC (Comité pour la RÉouverture de la Ligne Oloron Canfranc)
CREFCO (Coordinadora para la Reapertura del Ferrocarril Canfranc-Olorón)
Reopen Meigs Field
Policy Laundering Project
Meiklejohn Civil Liberties Institute
Roadblock Revelations (Checkpoint USA)
International Campaign Against Mass Surveillance
Watch lists and border controls (Canada)
Surveillance des Voyageurs (Canada)
No PNR! (EU)
Privacy International
The Privacy Coalition
Statewatch (Europe)
European Digital Rights (EDRI)
CivilLiberties.eu
NO2ID (UK)
no border network
Online Rights Canada
Vote Data Protection 2016
Omni Med
Pacific Environment
Foreign Policy In Focus
National War Tax Resistance Coordinating Committee
Courage to Resist
Not Your Soldier Project
ProgressiveSecretary.org
Project Laundry List
Santorum
Peace & Justice Studies Association
Kashmiri American Council
Kashmiri American Council (Facebook)
Alternatives to Marriage Project
Transportation for a Livable City
National Association of Railroad Passengers
Transportation for America
National Rail Corridors Initiative
OneRail Coalition
National Arts Festival of S. Africa (Grahamstown)
Airport (Ian Anderson)
Airport Graphics (AIGA/ACI/ICAO 9636)
Gixen eBay Sniper
Silver Bay

Help travellers reach the Internet
by running a Tor relay
Tips for travellers on censorware and Internet blocking

Blogs and Columns

Ruth Radetsky
Eric Muller
Discourse.net (Michael Froomkin)
The Laboratorium (James Grimmelmann)
Will's Way (Will Doherty)
ruk.ca (Peter Rukavina)
Erik Josefsson (mostly in Swedish)
Phil Mocek
Jetsetting Terrorist
Real in L.A. (Sarah Forth)
NeoConOpticon
Terminal Man (Brendan Ross)
no god blog (American Atheists)
xkcd
Sue Katz: Consenting Adult
Privacy Lives (Melissa Ngo)
Jon Carroll
Global Voices
Consumer Law & Policy Blog (Public Citizen)
Dykes To Watch Out For (Alison Bechdel)
Privacy.org (EPIC/Privacy International)
Skating on Stilts (Stewart Baker)
Watchlist Law (Jeff Kahn)
Coyote Crossing (Chris Clarke)
Edible Geography
Mayer Hillman
Geoge Monbiot
NRDC Switchboard: Aviation
Kashmir Solidarity Network
Mazameen (Mohamad Junaid)
Love, Sex, Romance and Travel (Jeannette Belliveau)
Ian Welsh
The eXiled online
Where in the world is Ms. Cathy?
Notes & Errata (Mark Morford)
Export Law Blog (Clif Burns et al.)
Sentencing Law and Policy
Jay Stanley @ ACLU Blog of Rights
Bruce Schneier on Security
Deep Links (EFF)
BOFH (The Register)
Pogo Was Right
Improbable Research
Pub Rants
The Content Farm
net.wars (Wendy M. Grossman)
The Other Glass (Wendy M. Grossman)
Identity Crisis (dot Name)
Slight Paranoia (Chris Soghoian)
Chris Soghoian's travel blog
Surveillance State (Chris Soghoian)
The Aging Rebel
Travel Technology (Norm Rose)
Jay Campbell (thebeat.travel)
Leaving America (Ken Smith)
Knife Tricks (Paul Karl Lukacs)
nomadicity
States Without Nations
Ask The Pilot (Patrick Smith)
Ask My Sky Mom (Danielle Gibeault)
Elliott.org (Christopher Elliott)
tnooz ("talking travel tech")
I Hate Ryanair (the Web site Ryanair tried to silence)
Brown Equals Terrorist (Ian Spiers)
Emergent Chaos (Adam Shostack)
Stupid Security (Nat Howard)
Homeland Stupidity (Michael Hampton)
A Glimpse of the World (Howard W. French)
Dan Froomkin
Friskodude (Carl Parkes)
Art, Truth, and Politics (Michael Wehle)
The Long Way to Peace (Toby Jacobrown)
A Fistful of Euros
The Lowe Road (David Lowe)
On the Record (Ann Harrison)
Spychips RFID blog (Katherine Albrecht and Liz McIntyre)
Lextext (Bret Fausett)
The Next Net (Patrick Vande Walle)
Bill Ayers
Credit Slips
Matt Meyer @ New Clear Vision
Matt Meyer @ Waging Nonviolence
Hello Kitty Hell
Mission Mission
Justice for Amilcar Perez-Lopez
(Shot dead 6 times in the back by SFPD, 26 Feb. 2015)
The Swellesley Report
Prohibit Child Genital Mutilation
Intact America
Caliber SF
Bambino's Curse: Diary of a Red Sox Fan

Personal Web Sites

James Groleau
David Harris
Jeremy Seabrook
Lynn Fitz-Hugh
MaidAsMuse.com (Aífe Murray)
World Dream Bank (Chris Wayan)
Wu Zhang
ComputerBytesMan.com (Richard M. Smith)
Jacqueline Stevens
Kathryn Joyce
Roger Clarke
Digital Painting (Rhoda Grossman)

Notices

Disclosures & Disclaimers
All advice and recommendations are the personal opinions of Edward Hasbrouck, and do not necessarily represent the views of my publishers, employers, or clients.

Copyright © 1991-2017 Edward Hasbrouck (ORCID 0000-0001-9698-7556), except as otherwise noted. Caricature by Rhoda Grossman, www.digitalpainting.com. Linking welcomed and encouraged, but reproduction permitted by permission only.

Use of any information obtained from this site for the purpose of sending unsolicited bulk e-mail is expressly forbidden, and is a violation of your license to use this copyrighted material.

RSS 2.0 feed of this blog

Powered by

Movable Type Open Source 5.2.13

Pegasus Mail

Pegasus Mail by David Harris

around-the-world and multi-stop airline tickets from Airtreks.com